On-Market vs. Off-Market Transactions

On-Market vs. Off-Market Transactions

Commercial real estate can sell through on-market or off-market transactions. Both methods have their advantages and disadvantages, so the right choice depends on the property and the likely buyer.

On-market transactions

On-market transactions take the shotgun approach to selling. First, the broker performs a market analysis and usually sets an asking price. Then the property owner and the broker sign a formal listing agreement. Next, the broker prepares marketing materials that show all the relevant information a buyer would need to determine their interest in the property.

The broker usually displays a “For Sale” sign on the property in the most visible location. The property also usually appears on the listing broker’s website, and possibly on a national database like LoopNet or CoStar. In addition, the broker may discuss the property with a few key buyers and some of the local brokers that deal in that specific product type.

After a period of time, the phone starts ringing. The broker then spends his time fielding questions, arranging on-site visits and, hopefully, negotiating offers and eventually closing the sale.

The great thing about on-market transactions is that the broker covers the entire market quickly and efficiently. As a result, anyone in the market for that type of property will know that the owner’s property is available for sale.

Off-market transactions

Off-market transactions take a rifled approach to selling. The property owner and the broker usually still sign a fee agreement, but there is no “listing” agreement. In fact, the objective is not to show the property to the entire market. Instead, the broker shows it to a handful of “very qualified”, targeted buyers that the broker knows personally.

Marketing material tends to be sparse. It often excludes many of the key facts that a potential buyer would need to fully determine interest in buying the property. Before the seller turns over sensitive information, attorneys need to review a confidentiality agreement and the buyer needs to sign it. Sensitive information includes financing, appraisals, market studies, operating statements and rent rolls.

In an off-market transaction, the broker’s role is to identify the “best” buyers for that particular property. The broker then discusses it with them, rather than with the entire market. In many cases, a seller will also restrict the list of potential buyers or require that the broker register each potential buyer.

Which method is better?

So, which method is better? It depends on what you are selling and to whom.

On-market methods are the best way to find local buyers. Buildings attractive to local buyers include owner/user-type buildings, buildings in rough neighborhoods or low traffic areas, and special use buildings. They also include buildings occupied by local businesses and smaller buildings slated for redevelopment. For these types of buildings, local buyers are the best buyers because they understand local issues and the local market.

In addition, big buyers shy away from small buildings. It takes roughly the same amount of resources to manage a small building as a big building, and big buyers usually have a limited number of asset managers. Large buyers like sovereign funds, insurance companies and pension funds also have very large pools of money to place “on-the-street”. Therefore, they often can’t spend the time to even look at a smaller deal.

Really large buyers will only be interested in individual properties or portfolios with values over one hundred million dollars. Big buyers also have very narrow criteria for what they will and won’t buy. Finally, they require a large amount of due diligence that sellers of smaller buildings may not be able to provide.

Why institutional buyers prefer off-market deals

Institutional buyers, REITs, and large real estate management firms will look at any property that fits their investment profile. However, they are more likely to be interested in an off-market deal than an on-market deal. The reason is simple. They want the respect that they believe they deserve because of their legitimate ability to close. They also don’t want to compete with unqualified buyers that will drive up the price of a property with unrealistic offers. Instead, they would much rather wait until the seller has spent months falling in and out of escrow. Then they go in with a reasonable offer backed up by their unquestionable ability to close.

As a rule, buildings priced under twenty-five million dollars sell better using the on-market method. Buildings or portfolios priced over twenty-five million sell better using the off-market method.

Buildings with difficult issues also sell better off-market, where the broker has the time to explain the idiosyncrasies of the deal to each buyer. In this manner, the buyer that goes into escrow is far less likely to fall out because of an undisclosed issue. The broker can also target the buyers that are familiar with handling the types of issues associated with that particular property.

Lastly, the “best” buyers are more willing to spend time analyzing a property if they know they have a real shot at closing the deal. They will also run it past their investment committee. After all, it takes time and resources to analyze a building that an institution or publicly-held real estate firm is interested in purchasing. Nothing is more frustrating for a big buyer than to go after a deal and lose it to a smaller, no name buyer that has no ability to close.

Brokerage firm requirements

One last point. Many of the national brokerage firms have requirements for how their agents handle listings. For example, some require that every property appears on the company website within a certain amount of time from signing the listing. Some firms also require that affiliate agents may sell those listings no matter what their qualifications. In addition, many firms do not allow off-market listings.

Whichever method an owner chooses, it really gets down to selecting the right broker to manage the sale of their particular property. Remember, when it comes to commercial real estate, ten percent of the brokers sell ninety percent of the property.

Related articles